|
gptkbp:instanceOf
|
High Court of Australia case
|
|
gptkbp:alsoKnownAs
|
gptkb:Love_v_The_Commonwealth;_Thoms_v_The_Commonwealth
|
|
gptkbp:appellantHeritage
|
Aboriginal Australian descent
|
|
gptkbp:appellantNationality
|
gptkb:New_Zealand_(Brendan_Thoms)
gptkb:Papua_New_Guinea_(Daniel_Love)
|
|
gptkbp:appellantStatus
|
Non-citizen permanent residents
|
|
gptkbp:application
|
gptkb:Brendan_Thoms
gptkb:Daniel_Love
|
|
gptkbp:citation
|
[2020] HCA 3
|
|
gptkbp:constitution
|
gptkb:Section_51(xix)_of_the_Australian_Constitution
|
|
gptkbp:country
|
gptkb:Australia
|
|
gptkbp:date
|
11 February 2020
|
|
gptkbp:deportationIssue
|
Appellants subject to deportation under Migration Act 1958
|
|
gptkbp:dissentingOpinionBy
|
gptkb:Gageler_J
gptkb:Keane_J
gptkb:Kiefel_CJ
|
|
https://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#label
|
Love v Commonwealth; Thoms v Commonwealth
|
|
gptkbp:impact
|
Implications for immigration law and Indigenous rights in Australia
|
|
gptkbp:judge
|
gptkb:High_Court_of_Australia
|
|
gptkbp:legalIssue
|
Whether Aboriginal Australians can be considered 'aliens' under section 51(xix) of the Australian Constitution
|
|
gptkbp:legalRepresentation
|
Ron Merkel QC (for Love)
Stephen Keim SC (for Thoms)
|
|
gptkbp:majorityOpinionBy
|
gptkb:Bell_J
gptkb:Edelman_J
gptkb:Gordon_J
gptkb:Nettle_J
|
|
gptkbp:mediaCoverage
|
Extensive national media attention in Australia
|
|
gptkbp:predecessor
|
Status of Aboriginal Australians in relation to Australian constitutional law
|
|
gptkbp:principle
|
Tripartite test for Aboriginality (descent, self-identification, community acceptance)
|
|
gptkbp:relatedTo
|
gptkb:Mabo_v_Queensland_(No_2)
gptkb:Plaintiff_S99/2016_v_Minister_for_Immigration_and_Border_Protection
|
|
gptkbp:response
|
gptkb:Commonwealth_of_Australia
|
|
gptkbp:result
|
Aboriginal Australians cannot be considered 'aliens' under the Constitution, even if not citizens
|
|
gptkbp:significance
|
First time High Court recognised a constitutional distinction for Aboriginal Australians regarding 'alien' status
|
|
gptkbp:subject
|
gptkb:constitutional_law
Indigenous people
Citizenship law
|
|
gptkbp:bfsParent
|
gptkb:Love_v_Commonwealth
|
|
gptkbp:bfsLayer
|
6
|