Department of Commerce v. New York
GPTKB entity
Statements (47)
| Predicate | Object |
|---|---|
| gptkbp:instanceOf |
legal case
|
| gptkbp:caseOutcome |
The citizenship question was not included in the 2020 census.
Set a precedent for future census-related legal challenges. |
| gptkbp:caseTypes |
18-966
|
| gptkbp:consequences |
Potential undercount of immigrant populations.
|
| gptkbp:controversy |
Lack of evidence supporting the need for the question.
Concerns over privacy and data security. Discriminatory impact on minority communities. Historical precedent against citizenship questions. Violation_of_the_Administrative_Procedure_Act. |
| gptkbp:court |
Reversed lower court's ruling.
|
| gptkbp:decidedBy |
gptkb:Supreme_Court_of_the_United_States
June 27, 2019 |
| gptkbp:filedIn |
April 23, 2019
|
| gptkbp:futurePlans |
Potential changes in representation and funding.
|
| gptkbp:historical_analysis |
Extensive legal analysis in law journals.
|
| gptkbp:historicalContext |
Part of ongoing debates about immigration and representation.
|
| https://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#label |
Department of Commerce v. New York
|
| gptkbp:impact |
Influenced public policy on census data collection.
|
| gptkbp:involves |
census citizenship question
|
| gptkbp:judges |
gptkb:Justice_Brett_Kavanaugh
gptkb:Justice_Neil_Gorsuch gptkb:Justice_Samuel_Alito Justice Clarence Thomas Judicial review of executive actions. |
| gptkbp:legalStatus |
gptkb:American_Civil_Liberties_Union
gptkb:New_York_Attorney_General's_Office Addressed the legality of adding a citizenship question to the census. Whether_the_Secretary_of_Commerce's_decision_to_add_a_citizenship_question_was_lawful. |
| gptkbp:mediaCoverage |
Significant media attention during the case.
|
| gptkbp:notableEvent |
Administrative Procedure Act
Census Act |
| gptkbp:notableFeature |
588 U.S. 2019
|
| gptkbp:outcome |
The_Supreme_Court_blocked_the_addition_of_a_citizenship_question_to_the_2020_census.
|
| gptkbp:politicalAffiliation |
gptkb:State_of_New_York
gptkb:Department_of_Commerce Various states and organizations |
| gptkbp:politicalParty |
gptkb:Chief_Justice_John_Roberts
|
| gptkbp:precedent |
Impact on future census-related litigation.
|
| gptkbp:publicAccess |
Controversial and widely debated.
Statements from advocacy groups. Statements from government officials. |
| gptkbp:publications |
Supreme_Court_opinions_and_briefs.
|
| gptkbp:relatedEvent |
Changes in census data collection practices.
Increased scrutiny of census-related policies. |
| gptkbp:relatedPatent |
gptkb:City_of_San_Jose_v._Trump
gptkb:National_Urban_League_v._Ross |