| gptkbp:instanceOf | gptkb:philosophy 
 | 
                        
                            
                                | gptkbp:alternativeName | Soft determinism 
 | 
                        
                            
                                | gptkbp:centralQuestion | Can moral responsibility exist if determinism is true? 
 | 
                        
                            
                                | gptkbp:concerns | Free will Determinism
 
 | 
                        
                            
                                | gptkbp:contrastsWith | Hard determinism Libertarianism (metaphysics)
 
 | 
                        
                            
                                | gptkbp:debatedBy | gptkb:Ethics gptkb:Metaphysics
 gptkb:Philosophy_of_action
 
 | 
                        
                            
                                | gptkbp:discusses | gptkb:Internet_Encyclopedia_of_Philosophy gptkb:Stanford_Encyclopedia_of_Philosophy
 
 | 
                        
                            
                                | gptkbp:field | Philosophy of free will 
 | 
                        
                            
                                | gptkbp:influencedBy | gptkb:Ancient_Greek_philosophy Enlightenment philosophy
 
 | 
                        
                            
                                | gptkbp:notableFigure | gptkb:A.J._Ayer gptkb:Daniel_Dennett
 gptkb:David_Hume
 gptkb:John_Locke
 gptkb:Thomas_Hobbes
 gptkb:Harry_Frankfurt
 
 | 
                        
                            
                                | gptkbp:opposedBy | gptkb:Incompatibilism 
 | 
                        
                            
                                | gptkbp:position | Free will and determinism are compatible 
 | 
                        
                            
                                | gptkbp:relatedConcept | Hard determinism Libertarianism (metaphysics)
 
 | 
                        
                            
                                | gptkbp:subspecies | Classical compatibilism Contemporary compatibilism
 Revisionist compatibilism
 
 | 
                        
                            
                                | gptkbp:bfsParent | gptkb:Free_Will 
 | 
                        
                            
                                | gptkbp:bfsLayer | 5 
 | 
                        
                            
                                | https://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#label | Compatibilism 
 |