|
gptkbp:instanceOf
|
gptkb:UK_Supreme_Court_case
|
|
gptkbp:application
|
gptkb:Cavendish_Square_Holding_BV
gptkb:ParkingEye_Ltd
|
|
gptkbp:citation
|
gptkb:[2015]_UKSC_16
|
|
gptkbp:country
|
gptkb:United_Kingdom
|
|
gptkbp:date
|
2015-11-04
|
|
gptkbp:fullName
|
gptkb:Cavendish_Square_Holding_BV_v_Talal_El_Makdessi;_ParkingEye_Ltd_v_Beavis
|
|
gptkbp:judge
|
gptkb:Lord_Neuberger
gptkb:Lord_Clarke
gptkb:Lord_Mance
gptkb:Lord_Toulson
gptkb:Supreme_Court_of_the_United_Kingdom
gptkb:Lord_Sumption
gptkb:Lord_Carnwath
gptkb:Lord_Hodge
|
|
gptkbp:legalSubject
|
contract law
liquidated damages
penalty clauses
|
|
gptkbp:neutralCitation
|
gptkb:[2015]_UKSC_16
|
|
gptkbp:overruledBy
|
gptkb:Dunlop_Pneumatic_Tyre_Co_Ltd_v_New_Garage_&_Motor_Co_Ltd_[1915]_AC_79
|
|
gptkbp:predecessor
|
penalty clause doctrine in English law
|
|
gptkbp:principle
|
legitimate interest test
reformulated test for penalty clauses
distinction between primary and secondary obligations
|
|
gptkbp:publishedIn
|
gptkb:UK_Supreme_Court_Judgments
|
|
gptkbp:response
|
gptkb:Barry_Beavis
gptkb:Talal_El_Makdessi
|
|
gptkbp:result
|
appeal allowed in part
Makdessi clause not a penalty
ParkingEye's charge not a penalty
|
|
gptkbp:subject
|
enforceability of penalty clauses in contracts
|
|
gptkbp:bfsParent
|
gptkb:R_(SG)_v_Secretary_of_State_for_Work_and_Pensions
|
|
gptkbp:bfsLayer
|
7
|
|
https://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#label
|
[2015] UKSC 16
|